001.92 Disadvantages of citation index and Hirsch and using other scientometrics

Polyanin A. D. (Bauman Moscow State Technical University/Ishlinsky Institute for Problems in Mechanics)

CITATION, SCIENTOMETRIC INDICE, HIRSCH INDEX, PERFORMANCE EVALUATION, THE MAX-IMUM CITATION INDEXES.


doi: 10.18698/2309-3684-2014-1-131144


The paper deals with the citation index and h-index, which are the main scientometric indices, currently used for evaluating the performance of scientists and university professors. The author indicates their main disadvantages and considers a number of illustra-tive examples. The study shows that the normalized citation index (taking into account the presence of co-authors) has a number of important advantages in comparison with other scientometric indices. The author proposes new indices — the maximum citation indices, which can be easily calculated, have a simple and clear interpretation and have a number of distinct advantages in comparison with the h-index.


[1] Hirsch J.E. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 2005, vol. 102(46), pp. 16569–16572. URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0508025
[2] Egghe L. Scientometrics, 2006, vol. 69, no. 1, pp. 131–152.
[3] Tsyganov A.V. Upravlenie bol'shimi sistemami – Control of large systems, 2013, iss. 44, pp. 248–261.
[4] Shtovba S.D., Shtovba E.V. Upravlenie bol'shimi sistemami — Control of large systems, 2013, iss. 44, pp. 262–278.
[5] Sbornik "Igra v tsyfir', ili kak teper' otsenivaiut trud uchenogo" [Coll. art. "Playing figures, or as we now estimate the scientist's work"], Moscow, MTsNMO Publ., 2011, 72 p.
[6] Indeksy tsitirovaniia rabot rossiiskikh uchenykh (proekty “Kto est' kto v rossiiskoi nauke” i “Korpus ekspertov”) [Citation indiсes in works of Russian scientists (project "Who's who in Russian science" and "Experts corpus")]. URL: http://expertcorps.ru/science/whoiswho
[7] Hirch J. E. Scientometrics, 2010, vol. 85, p. 741.
[8] Rousseau R., Garcia-Zorita C., Sanz-Casado E. Journal of Informetrics, 2013, vol. 7, pp. 294–300.
[9] Georgiev G. Indeks Khirsha nado iskliuchit' iz otsenki uchenykh [Hirsch index should be excluded from the evaluation of scientists]. Nauka i tekhnologii Rossii — Science and technologies of Russia, 17 November 2011.
[10] Polianin A.D. Nauchnoe soobshchestvo – Scientific community, 2013, no. 8–9, pp. 20–22.
[11] Neretin Yu. Nezavisimaia gazeta – Independent paper, 10 December 2013.
[12] Kotliar P. Fiziki-ginekologi i matematiki-literatory. Uchenye raskritikovali proekt «Karta rossiiskoi nauki» [Physicists-gynecologists and mathematicians-writers. Scientists have criticized the project "Map of Russian science."].


Polyanin A. Disadvantages of citation index and Hirsch and using other scientometrics. Маthematical Modeling and Coтputational Methods, 2014, №1 (1), pp. 131-144



Download article

Колличество скачиваний: 849